Why AI Systems May Never Be Secure and What Businesses Should Do
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly becoming embedded in everyday business processes and decision-making. However, a recent Economist article (Sept 22, 2025) highlights a sobering reality: AI systems may never be fully secure. This is not cause for alarm, but rather a call for vigilance and layered safeguards. Here, we summarize the key points, takeaways, and insights relevant for Canadian businesses and financial leaders.
Key Points
-
Intrinsic Vulnerabilities
-
AI models, especially large language and generative models, are statistical learners that generalize. This makes them inherently susceptible to manipulation.
-
Traditional “patch and defend” security methods are insufficient.
-
-
The “Lethal Trifecta” of Risk
-
Complexity and Opacity: Internal workings are difficult to interpret.
-
Generalization: Models can react unpredictably to novel inputs.
-
Real-world Interaction: AI connects with APIs, data pipelines, and external systems, expanding the attack surface.
-
-
Limits of Training-Based Safety
-
Techniques like adversarial training and reinforcement learning with human feedback help, but cannot eliminate risks.
-
Cleverly designed prompts can still bypass safeguards.
-
-
Attack Surface Beyond the Model
-
Vulnerabilities often lie in the environment: APIs, infrastructure, and data pipelines.
-
The security of these systems is just as important as the AI itself.
-
-
Recommended Mitigation Strategies
-
Defence in Depth: Use layered protections like input sanitization, anomaly detection, and kill switches.
-
Red Teaming: Continuously test systems against adversarial attacks.
-
External Oversight: Encourage audits, transparency, and regulatory compliance.
-
Access Controls: Limit exposure by compartmentalizing sensitive tasks.
-
Monitoring: Track outputs and behaviours for anomalies.
-
Plan for Residual Risk: Accept that vulnerabilities will remain; build fallback and human oversight mechanisms.
-
Business Takeaways
-
Ongoing Process: AI security is not a one-time fix. It requires continuous adaptation.
-
Holistic Approach: Combine technical, organizational, and regulatory strategies.
-
Residual Risk Management: Treat AI like financial risk, mitigate, monitor, and plan for failure scenarios.
-
Deployment Matters: The context in which AI operates can create risks greater than the model itself.
-
Strategic Humility: No system is invulnerable; overconfidence is dangerous.
Insights for Canadian Finance Leaders
-
Risk Governance: CFOs should incorporate AI security into enterprise risk frameworks.
-
Regulatory Preparedness: Canadian businesses should anticipate AI-related compliance and disclosure requirements.
-
Operational Safeguards: Deploy monitoring and fallback systems to protect financial processes.
-
Audit and Oversight: Push for third-party validation of AI security and compliance.
Bottom Line
AI security is best seen as a continuous contest between defenders and attackers. As protections strengthen, adversaries evolve. Complete safety is unlikely, but businesses can approach AI risks much like financial risks: through layered safeguards, active oversight, and well-prepared contingency plans.
Next Step for Savvy CFO Clients: Assess where AI touches your financial operations. Identify potential vulnerabilities and then implement layered safeguards to mitigate the risk.