Is America's Valuation Bubble About to Break Its Democracy?
Updated Democracy Health Index (DHI) – 2025 Edition. Democracy isn’t just an ideology — it’s an infrastructure. And like any infrastructure, its stress points reveal themselves when the economy overheats or breaks down. With asset valuations at historic highs, fiscal discipline absent, and political parties abandoning restraint, Martin Wolf of the Financial Times recently warned: “This is a Wile E. Coyote moment. The U.S. has already gone off the cliff. The only question is when it looks down.” In that context, Savvy's Democracy Health Index (DHI) is more relevant than ever — not as a post-mortem, but as a leading indicator.
What Is the DHI?
The DHI (Democracy Health Index) is a forward-looking, signal-based assessment developed by Savvy-CFO to track the operational health of democratic systems. It considers:
- Institutional stability and separation of powers
- Media freedom and civic access to truth
- Economic policy coherence and fairness
- Political will to protect minority rights
- Structural risks like gerrymandering, judicial interference, or legislative gridlock
Scored out of 100, the DHI is designed to help analysts, leaders, and citizens see beyond sentiment — and identify where democratic erosion may be silently advancing.
――――――――――――――――――――
2025 Snapshot: What the Bubble Is Telling Us
This year’s scoring update reflects an alarming yet paradoxical truth: the U.S. economy’s artificial strength may be masking democratic fragility.
Economic Recklessness as Democratic Risk
- The private equity hiring frenzy, covered in WSJ’s "JPMorgan and Goldman Are Losing Their Grip", is not a sign of prosperity, it’s a sign of asset speculation peaking.
- As Martin Wolf explains, bipartisan abandonment of fiscal responsibility, paired with growing appetite for "magical thinking" creates unsustainable debt and rising inequality.
- When economic pain arrives (as it must), the institutions Americans depend on to manage the fallout — Congress, the courts, local governments — may already be too polarized or hollowed out to act.
External Shock, Internal Consequences
- A burst bubble won’t stop at U.S. borders. Former allies economically exposed to U.S. capital flows, defense spending, or tech monopolies may also feel strain.....Canada included.
- These externalities matter. Democratic health is not isolated; it’s part of a shared, networked system.
――――――――――――――――――――
Provisional 2025 DHI Scores (Preliminary)
Final scores will be published after expert review on [August 31, 2025].
Country |
2024 DHI |
2025 DHI (Prelim) |
Notes |
USA |
64 |
59 |
Fiscal recklessness, legal interference, civic volatility |
Canada |
75 |
73 |
Continued executive centralization, foreign influence vulnerabilities |
UK |
68 |
66 |
Disinformation fatigue, judicial mistrust |
EU Avg |
72 |
70 |
Rightward shift in policy and rule-of-law backsliding in member states |
――――――――――――――――――――
Can Both Be Prevented?
Perhaps. A sober reckoning, fiscal, political, and civic; might still avert both collapse and authoritarian drift. But it will require something rare: coordinated, unglamorous action across institutions.
If the economy breaks first, it may just jolt democracy back to life. But the cost; social trust, global partnerships, and individual livelihoods, will be long-lasting and extreme.
Better to act before the fall. But as Wolf reminds us, the cliff’s edge doesn’t wait for consensus.
――――――――――――――――――――
What to Watch Next
- US. fiscal negotiations post-election
- Judicial independence under second-term pressures
- Disinformation and media consolidation trends
- Canada’s response to rising geopolitical and trade alignment pressure
――――――――――――――――――――
Related Reading
-
When the Meme Isn’t a Joke: Democracy Metrics and the Rising Threat to Canada
– The original Savvy-CFO blog introducing the DHI and why Canada’s democratic stressors demand close attention. -
WSJ: JPMorgan and Goldman Are Losing Their Grip
– Wall Street Journal’s report on junior banker poaching by private equity firms — a leading indicator of asset-market froth. -
Martin Wolf on the Coming Fall of the U.S. Economy
– Podcast interview with Martin Wolf outlining how fiscal recklessness and inflated markets point to an impending crash.
――――――――――――――――――――
The DHI is a tool, not a verdict. Democracies don’t die overnight — but they do corrode quietly. If the economic signals are loud today, it’s because the political ones are whispering the same story.
Stay alert. The next update could be pivotal.